I have been a fan of Star Wars for as long as I can remember. However, like all fans brought up to love the series by their fathers, I am a lover of the old trilogy – A New Hope, Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi – and not so much the new one – The Phantom Menace, Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith.
However, it struck me recently that I could no longer remember what had even happened in the new trilogy, despite constantly reiterating that I disliked them and chiding those who felt otherwise. And thus, I rewatched them. Oh boy, did I rewatch them.
WARNING: apologies to Patrick Star, but this may contain spoilers if you do, in fact, live under a rock.
Episode 1: The Phantom Menace (IMDb)
As a child, I don’t think there was anything I hated more than this film. When I decided to rewatch it, I honestly expected to either laugh or cry at how bad it was. But this film is on a whole other level of badness -
It’s just plain boring.
Take the plot, for example. Some people don’t like new trade laws and so decide to occupy Naboo, all while squabbling over legalities and politics. Meanwhile, some Jedi policemen types decide to escort the elected Queen (elected Queen? They should have chosen a better word) elsewhere, during which mission they land on the ‘dangerous’ Tatooine (where nothing dangerous happens to them) and put THEIR SAFETY, THEIR SHIP AND ALL OF THEIR MONEY at the mercy of a ten year old boy who does nothing more than profess to be kinda good at racing and building things. After, by some miracle, he wins them stuff, they all go back to the planet nation thingy to have an extremely short war… about trade.
I kept waiting for something, anything, to happen, but nothing eventuated, with the plot plodding along, with nothing even mildly exciting happening, unless you count pointless action sequences that were more an exercise in graphic design than anything else (I like my battles epic and laden with drama – Cloud City, anyone?). The only person who promised to be mildly interesting – Darth Maul, a.k.a. spikey red-faced guy – never spoke a single word and only had one real battle in which he did have a rather spectacular death by being cut in half. Everything else that was mildly interesting just served as a teaser for all the other films.
Speaking of Darth Maul, is he the titular Phantom Menace? Or is it Darth Sidious, a.k.a. Senator Palpatine? Is it Anakin? WHO???
In the end, I ask myself, as many fans have done time and time again: What on earth was George Lucas thinking? The film added nothing to the franchise, except for showing Anakin when he was young and at the beginning of his Jedi training/relationship with Padme. Yet, we learn next to nothing about the man who will later become Darth Vader. I mean, he has a mother (who he loves), mad Jedi skillz and a boner for Natalie Portman. But that could have probably been ascertained in a much shorter running time.
Episode II: Attack of the Clones (IMDb)
This movie is where shit actually begins to go down. Anakin grows up into a semi-competent actor, who is nice to look at if nothing else, while Padme mysteriously remains the same age, making their relationship decidedly less creepy (particularly with the politic decision not to reveal their ages in the movie universe). And thus we have the first shades of requited romance in the new trilogy, made all the more dramatic by the whole Jedi-cannot-love thing.
In addition to this, an actual intergalactic problem is happening as nation planets are abandoning the Senate, creating the Separatist movement in the wake of an ineffective intergalactic government. This creates some legit political drama on a much larger scale than the Naboo trade dispute.
Thus, we actually have a two-layered plot! Such luxury!
I actually quite like this film. It was a lovely marriage of all the things I like to see in movies – fancy effects, plot, romance and great action sequences. One of my favourite action sequences in the series is in this film – the Roman Games-esqe attempted execution of Obi Wan, Anakin and Padme. There are cool animals, a teary love scene at the beginning and the whole thing eventually breaks into a giant battle at the end – I love it! C3PO comes up with a few hilariously punny lines here (“I am beside myself!”; “This is such a drag”), along with one of my favourite lines – “I am programmed for ettiquette, not destruction!”
I also really like the plot with the clone army – here Lucas actually put his new animation technology to good use with the stretched white aliens of Kamino.
Plus, who could forget the bad-ass confrontation between Yoda and Count Dooku (greatest name EVER). They don’t even need lightsabers, just SHEER WILLPOWER.
There are definitely problems – pacing being, yet again, a serious issue. I hate how they rushed the ending and the marriage of Anakin and Padme. Yes, we the viewership knew they liked each other, however, marriage is another kettle of fish with hadn’t even been discussed. It was very random, even if the wedding dress was SO PRETTY.
All in all, I don’t understand a lot of the hate for this film. Sure, Jar Jar Binks makes some strange and disturbing appearances as a stand-in for Senator Amidala, and some of the acting is laughable, but overall there is nothing overly offensive about it. Sure, I would rank it lower than all the other films in the series, excepting The Phantom Menace, but it’s still pretty good.
Episode III: Revenge of the Sith (IMDb)
This is the most balanced, and, by mass consensus, the best film in the New Trilogy. It manages to juggle the outbreak of a civil war in the Republic with actually believable marital discussions between Anakin and Padme (who are mysteriously still not suspected of having a relationship by anyone except Obi Wan). Furthermore, the film maps Anakin’s transformation into the Darth Vader we always knew he would become, as he is manipulated by the Chancellor Palpatine into distrusting the Jedi Order and putting faith into the powers of the Dark Side of the Force.
The film also deals with some deeper issues – that of who and what truly is ‘good’ and ‘bad’. Lucas has always polarised the two before, with the original trilogy having very clear lines between the protagonists and the antagonists, but this film sees human nature as it truly is – a mixture, where nothing is truly good or truly evil, with each label depending entirely upon your point of view. In this sense, this is one of the most mature films of the Saga, and I am glad that this was the note George Lucas ended the films on (repeat the mantra: Clone Wars doesn’t count, Clones Wars doesn’t count).
We see and empathise with the path Anakin has chosen, understanding every decision he makes as he turns over to the Dark Side, even if we do realise that it’s bad and whatnot. Lines are blurred, allegiances shift and hearts sealed by the bonds of love, brotherhood and loyalty are broken – this is damn good filmmaking.
This film also sees the tragic end of the doomed love between Anakin and Padme. Their relationship in this film is beautifully portrayed with a maturity not seen in the Han/Leia relationship of the Original Trilogy. Excepting an overly cheesy greeting and a couple of “OMG I LOVE YOU SO MUCH” lines, it was pretty believable married people stuff.
In related news, there is a lot of bad-assery in this film. R2D2 is bad-ass from scene one, where he sets a bunch of drones on fire (booyah). The epic final battles are truly EPIC, and seeing Anakin/Obi Wan fight it out in parallel with Palpatine/Yoda is really cool – these scenes make me understand why Lucas wanted to wait for better graphics technology. I love the effects in the Original Trilogy, because Lucas makes it work – however, I don’t think Anakin’s dismemberment, the lava battle or the mad showdown in the Senate would have had quite the same impact with the quaint effects of yore.
~~~
Overall, I would say I enjoyed my foray back into the New Trilogy; it has been far too long. The Phantom Menace sucked, yes, but the other two were really enjoyable. Revenge of the Sith in particular was awesome – it deserves to be listed alongside the great films of the Original Trilogy.
All in all, this experience just showed me how much I really do love this franchise. I love the anticipation created by “A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away…”; I love the blasting noise of that amazing score; I love how unique and instantly recognisable everything about the series is; I love spotting robots playing American Football in the background of Attack of the Clones; I love the languages they created out of clicky noises; I love the silly names and the ridiculous aliens and the sassy robots and the crazy spaceships. Most of all, I love knowing how it’s going to end, but seeing how it plays out anyway.


























